Class 3 State Quarterfinal (Saturday): St. Pius Lancers at Dexter Bearcats
The St. Pius X Lancers should be favored by at least as many points in the Class 3 state quarterfinals than the two TDs The Geek touted the Lancers by last week. Dexter, unlike the Bearcats of four decades ago, doesn’t possess a quarterback that can throw a baseball 100 MPH. Earl Wheeler must still be proud of the 2026 Dexter Bearcats for going 8-4 this year, and defeating the sizzling Kennett Indians to earn DHS’s third straight district title. But there’s not much evidence that Dexter’s up on a way higher plane of performance than Park Hills, Caruthersville, or St. Clair this fall … teams that the Lancers beat about 200-to-12 in 16 frames.
Besides the fact that Saturday’s proud host has played in Week 13 every year since 2024, Dexter’s claim to being a tough out in the state Q-Final is that the Bearcats have noticeably improved, beating the Ste. Genevieve Dragons 28-13 in the District 1 postseason after getting torn an extra “e” by Ste. Genevieve in this regular season. Nevertheless, we know that out of all Mississippi Magazine teams, the SPX Lancers like seeing a decisive pick go their way. They won’t hit The Geek on a podcast for picking St. Pius to win.
Hill Valley’s defense is getting its swagger back, looking more like the Week 1-8 outfit that impressed fans beyond state borders, as opposed to the shaky unit of Weeks 9 and 11. The lineup’s healthy performers are no longer freaks, but in the majority instead. JV stopgaps have performed bravely and can (mostly) have a seat. St. Pius X held District 2’s runner-up St. Clair to a “virtual shutout” that was only marred by a mop-up touchdown with Quarter 4 expiring. The offense is seizing the bounty of field position and going bananas with it, racking up 800 yards of offense in two playoff wins. QB Evan Eckrich is 69% with four TDs and no INTs.
Dexter’s got matchup problems all over the place. 6’4″ senior Carson Hurt is a tremendous weapon who the Bearcats will want to get through SPX’s elite linebackers and into the open field, to try to match 1-v-1 against a less-tall safety such as sophomore Guy Bradford. But with Brody Ervin and Cody Shaver in dominant form again, Hurt is going to be a busy kid, blocking and tackling both ways, hoping to stem the tide of SPX’s running game before facing those same scholarship kids as a Tight End. Dexter Bearcats quarterback Will Guethle is an excellent dual-threat, but he hasn’t got one WR averaging 30+ YPG this season, according to Google. If the Google AI is misreading Dexter’s pay-to-read recaps with the wide receivers’ stats, we apologize.
St. Pius X can probably run the rock as successfully against Dexter as against the Lancers’ last two opponents. Dexter has been a vulnerable defense versus blue-collar opposition, giving up 27 points to a Kelly club that lost to the injury-thinned St. Vincent Indians 42-25 in the C2D1 Finals. Much like the 2026 St. Clair Bulldogs, there isn’t the uniform experience on the Bearcats’ sizable front to play 48:00 of sound defense against a lineup with two elite RBs, one elite WR, plus a Class 4-level OL like SPX’s. Dexter has a nice number of tall, agile CBs, but they’ll probably be drawn into trying to stop the run, supplementing a front-seven on which eight of the biggest 10 options next to Hurt are hurting for Grade 12 seasoning. (By the token above, there is a chance DHS can go “Chillicothe 1991” by rotating a Mighty-Mouse set of 185 lb. seniors into the Bearcats’ defensive front who can eat metal. HUDL viewing hours are finite.)
Could it be another romp for St. Pius X? The Geek imagines that it could. We’re excited about a state bracket in which just about all of the Show-Me Bowl hopefuls have a harder row to hoe than Hill Valley, beginning with Country Day’s unfamiliar matchup against Southern Boone, and the collision course St. Pius-KC and likely semifinalist Cassville may be on going into Turkey Day weekend. Nothing against the Dexter Bearcats, who would be SCARY as a senior-filled lineup – and whom could prove scary regardless.
More frightening is that the injury bug still hasn’t buzzed away from St. Pius. Hunter Hylton, the superlative junior LB and center for the Lancers, has been stricken with a worrisome injury, and could be sidelined for the quarterfinals. Coaches are concerned about what another change at center may do to the Lancers’ snapping. The Geek is just as worried about Hylton’s absence on defense, where juniors Krew Miller and Harrison Ray can keep dominating in the open field – if they aren’t busy tackling RBs themselves.
It’s strange how Hylton hides from Mississippi Magazine’s headlines and highlight reels. We profiled him in preseason, not realizing that he would turn into the Lancers’ “Kevin McHale” of this autumn, the relentless, underrated force who doesn’t get the National TV airtime of Magic and Larry. Ray, Cody Shaver, Brody Ervin, and Lynnden McCoin are hogging those “Larry Bird” moments. “McHale” has only (AHEM) led via 100+ total tackles – including 19 for-loss – while manning the pivot for a mighty ground game. He’d vie for the Lancers’ team lead in solo tackles over McCoin, were it not for this injury. Or, Hunter might do it anyway.
It was Hylton who inspired the neatest moment from the United Fidelity Bank Bowl’s video stream this season. His stats and his highlight reel were so impressive, it made the Gibson Southern announcer start yodeling. Like, the soft yodel that folks do when really impressed, but not necessarily for themselves. “There’s this “Geek” who analyzes Missouri football,” began a coach on the Pay-Per-View broadcast. “He’s real hyped on this St. Pius defense, and when you see the personnel you can understand why.”
Coach: Start at Hunter Hylton, the 5’11” junior who’s been in the starting lineup since last summer. He can play defensive end or linebacker, and he led St. Pius X in tackles-for-loss as a sophomore.”
Announcer: “owh’OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOooh.”
“Then we have junior cornerback Harrison Ray, who is 6’3,” and caught six interceptions last season.”
“owh’OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOooh.”
“There’s also defensive tackle David Schulte. 6’6″ senior. He is well over 300 pounds.”
“owh’OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOooh.”
… and so on. Seems at least two out of three of those “owh’OOOOOOs” will play Saturday, but you need a well-stocked linebacking corps in between your Big Guy and your Lanky Kid, and Hylton has been a key to that ingredient for SPX. Also, while the club has proven that it can mend injuries on the fly and keep gluing a winning lineup together like St. Louis CITY SC, last season’s center adjustments in later fall led to some dangerous mishaps, such as blundering two punt attempts against Montgomery County.
How will Hylton’s untimely injury impact the Dexter quarterfinal? Well, remember that Coach Ray’s injury reports can be pessimistic. Ray’s Week 11 midweek chat with The Geek had Mississippi Magazine writing that Brody Ervin was out, nearly half the defense was manned by JV kids, and why-oh-why did the Lancers have to face the “hot” St. Clair a week later, etc. Hylton is a tough cookie who earned his stripes as an underclassman. If he can play, he’ll perform well. It’s more a question of whether the Lancers’ coaches decide that they can trip Dexter without Hylton, to heal up the junior run-stuffer for a difficult Week 14.
It’s hard to say what will happen if Hylton takes the sit-and-return route. The Lancers could feel out-of-whack without their center, or they could decide that Hylton’s making a show of confidence by sitting out – in the sense that a loss would make Week 12 his last game of the year already – and play like hell not to let No. 53 down. Coaches can employ Lucas Reitzel at center in an adjusted offensive line, and they can also introduce David Schulte in the “Texas Roadhouse” offense – with a different server if needed.
Good news, though – Hylton is not the SPX Lancers’ starting Long Snapper. That job’s going to senior Gabe “Don’t Call Me Joan” Baez, who rushed onto the field to snap in Quarter 1 of the district final when the Lancers couldn’t seem to believe they had a fourth down already. It was that counter-waggle attempt by Eckrich that put SPX behind the sticks, but The Geek liked it so much that he hopes Hill Valley runs it 200 times. One bomb for a TD obviates the need for 15 perfect snaps on a drive downfield.
Hill Valley’s offense may opt to move slowly and steadily up the pitch, not wanting to run any Shotgun snaps on tricky timing that can sail over Eckrich’s head and cause a turnover. SPX’s other semi-platoon, with Hylton hampered, but a litany of other kids looking ready, thinks that the offense could punt all night and that St. Pius X would still shut down its opponents enough to win games, like the Baltimore Ravens of Y2K. They certainly got upset when The Geek predicted St. Clair would manufacture three meaningful touchdowns in Week 12. St. Pius could choose to play to the strength of its salty defense, and stay cautious with the rock.
Turnovers are the thing that could spark the upset for Dexter, a decorated foe that has too many developing cogs to make a real run at SPX otherwise. Hold onto the football, Lancers, and you’ll hold onto that Final Four bid. PREDICTION: LANCERS 28, DEXTER 7
Class 4 State Quarterfinal (Saturday): Festus Tigers at Vianney Golden Griffins
It’s the old lion against the young lion … in FRIDAY NIGHT LIGHTS … on a Saturday. Yes, folks, the matchup of Festus-at-Vianney includes the closest thing you can ever see to ‘Patrick Mahomes taking on Caleb Williams’ outside of an NFL scenario. It pits the incredible senior QB Parker Perry of Festus against the sterling freshman Harlan Futrell Jr. of the Vianney Golden Griffins.
Perry and Futrell have taken disparate paths to their meeting. Perry was injured in the second bout of the Varsity Tigers’ season, a loss to St. Mary’s that seemed to make a Midmeadow Lane slump official. After all, the Tigers had lost three tilts in a row, and they had no backup QB of Frank Reich-caliber ready to go. QB Quinnten O’ Brien was being thrown into the fire, a junior whom coaches had hoped to utilize to patch a gap at wide receiver. O’Brien began his trek as starting quarterback tentatively, not wanting to make a mistake, after watching Perry’s immaculate passing season of 2025. That’s when this season’s developments began to fall in favor of Festus, and O’Brien, and Perry, one right after the other, as the leaves turned. Brick by brick, a brand new fortress was built.
The Festus ’26 defense roared as The Geek expected it to, stonewalling rival Hillsboro High and Class 4 state runner-up Hannibal. That gave O’Brien a comfortable path to the garden. The junior started to put up numbers that reflected the newfound accuracy of the Tanglefoot passing game, leading the way as a conference win streak turned into something more. By the time Festus had prevailed seven times, sparking R-6’s current 9-0 streak, O’Brien passed and ran for 1500+ yards, tossing 10 TD passes.
Then it was Perry’s turn to return from his collarbone fracture, just like Brody Kube had done at Seckman. The senior had a vintage game against DeSoto in the District 1 semifinals, going 10-of-14 for 175 yards. Sikeston’s solid defense made things tougher on the returning phenom, but by the finals, Perry and the Tigers were soaring to another 20+ point win, and a third-straight district crown.
No. 4 has a restocked litany of downfield weapons, including the dominant Braydon Wilkes, and the emerging Keyshawn Hall. That combo’s backed by the senior tailback Kamden Yates, a threat to score a touchdown every time he takes a touch.
Futrell has stayed healthy for more-or-less the whole season at Vianney, which is impressive in-and-of itself considering how often he’s had to scramble from the pocket against Vianney’s tough opponents. Playing against a schedule of the powerful Metro Catholic, plus St. Pius-Festus, Class 4 rival Sullivan, and Ladue, Futrell has passed for nearly 3000 yards, and 63% completions, throwing 26 TD passes against 10 INTs.
The sensational 15-year-old has run for 600 yards and eight TDs, too, yet Vianney’s foremost running threat is the special senior running back Robert Eatherton, who is poised to break the 2000-yard season mark on his first handful of carries on Saturday.
So, why were Vianney’s outcomes so poor at times, other than that tough schedule, and the inexperience at QB? Vianney’s slate of annual opponents is brutal overall, but the STL Metro isn’t playing a whole lot of sound defense this year. Vianney has regretfully been Exhibit A in that regard. Ladue High had five scoring drives in 18:00 and led Vianney 31-14 at the half of a 50-27 victory. The Chaminade Red Devils, who had problems with Hazelwood’s weak sisters in the playoffs, rushed for 248 yards in a 51-29 victory over the Golden Griffins. Sullivan, which went 1-1 against Vianney this fall, ran for an immense 505 yards on VHS in Week 9.
Vianney’s defense bore down and held Sullivan to 321 yards in last weekend’s 35-14 revenge win for District 2’s championship. It’s clear that the Golden Griffins are focused on the here-and-now, ignoring a 5-7 record, in favor of looking at their accomplishments from recent weeks, defeating Union’s big pass rush and Sullivan’s mighty ground attack. What is the Tigers’ key to surviving an opponent that’s already accumulated 5000 yards of offense, and for which two 1000-yard receivers are mere role-players?
Festus may not have a choice but to score early, and score often. Yates can outrush Eatherton on a given Saturday, running behind the weight of R-6’s offensive line led by upperclassmen Carson Grass and Eli Tilley. Perry has to be careful against an opposing secondary that might be utilizing more of those quick WRs in DB spots in the postseason, accounting for Vianney’s enhanced fleetness of foot against Sullivan in the playoff rematch. But he’ll seek to throw long once Yates is established on the rush.
Futrell’s day is going to be one of flinging, scrambling, and scampering. Antonio Pinkston’s pass rush will run the freshman around, but that formula didn’t work for Union, which had collected more sacks that Lift For Life’s active front-seven prior to losing to the Griffins. Liam O’ Brien’s defensive backfield will be seriously tested by the Vianney passing game, but if they’re tested with a substantial lead to boost them, the pressure Futrell is under to produce TD drives could work to harm the frosh’s efforts.
Black & Gold may need to play its best game on offense of the 2026 playoffs, so far, to outscore Vianney on the latter’s home turf. If you listen to the coaches, praising how the Tigers’ postseason depth chart has turned out, there doesn’t seem to be a reason why Festus can’t do it. For once, it’s the offense that must set the defense up to succeed. PREDICTION: TIGERS 36, VIANNEY 30
Photo Credit: St. Pius X Football Facebook
