Is it time for more “Sports Therapy” for the Jefferson Blue Jays, days after the tearful, bittersweet District-Final-turned-fundraiser at Valle Catholic? Well, we can’t ask the brave, resilient Blue Jays themselves to gulp and go showing off any postseason awards just yet. But the grown-ups can handle it. Jefferson’s head coach Matt Atley, in hindsight of the unbelievable level of adversity faced by Jefferson’s season while the Week 11 tragedy became widely known, and the playoff win which was 100% certainly dedicated to JHS’s traumatized Junior Varsity, has already just about wrapped up this year’s award for COTY of the county’s Small Schools.
Yes, if the Festus Tigers or St. Pius Lancers defeat Kearney or St. Pius X-KC to win Missouri’s state title in a few weeks, then Atley will have competition for A+ coaching honors this year. Even still, we can’t think of a coaching staff that deserves higher praise than Jefferson’s, or how a local staff could get more credit than Atley’s group. Two JeffCo coaches, Atley and Scott Gerling of Northwest, had to help steer athletic departments through senseless, unspeakable tragedy and loss of life. Gerling’s bid was spectacular, but his Lions did not persevere to the extent of winning a playoff game. The Jefferson Blue Jays did.
Atley dealt with the unimaginable emotional blow at Jefferson while changing quarterbacks on the field. The Blue Jays had nothing better, it seemed, than to go with a freshman at QB in the district semifinals against Montgomery County. What the Wildcats might have been unaware of is that the “freshman” in question is one of the truly special rookies in a growing hotbed. Atley’s habit of scratching the Blue Jays’ game videos from HUDL archives, combined with the fact that Montgomery had to play in Week 10, allowed Logan Young’s skills and poise to sneak up on the Wildcats, who lost to a pair of TD runs from the frosh phenom.
What the Blue Jays community knew was that Atley’s QB change was 1% of his coaching job in Week 11. The horrible news that began to seep out on socials earlier this month had to have devastated Atley, while breaking the hearts of Principal Rouggly and a dozen assistant coaches and volunteers under Atley’s command. It would have been courageous for the Jefferson Blue Jays to show up and lose to Montgomery County 0-63 at that point. It shows phenomenal bravery that the teens even competed.
Atley didn’t just get the Blue Jays through to an offseason. Jefferson, in a show of defiance in the face of untold adversity, went on to coach better football than it did as the Jays dominated their QCC schedule this midseason, all while facing the crisis of a decade at Blue Jay Way.
Atley piloted the Blue Jays from one championship game to the next while maintaining his lineup’s excellent form in the semifinals, thanks to the players’ iron determination to go on and win for Asher and Rhett. What Atley and his coaches did as administrators, at the same moment, can’t be dismissed as “all about the players.” Atley’s office had to make it happen 100%.
Jefferson’s coaches consoled their players, ran a massive fundraising effort, coordinated with Valle on its own Donation counter, kept the story out of the papers, made sure everyone who would donate knew about it anyway, and led the team in a series of successful practices and games, despite a frosh QB taking over. That’s insane. It’s one of the greatest administrative efforts Mississippi Magazine has ever reported on. We wonder if Atley and Rouggly have even slept at all, or if they are machines.
You can let a team crisis turn you into a guidance counselor. Or, you can become a force-of-nature who leads the way in turning a dark moment into something that salves everyone’s spirits, giving your campus a legacy of perseverance that it can be proud of. Atley chose Door #2, somehow acing 3-4 roles at once, while helming the Varsity that scored a TD on a likely state champion.
Atley’s 2023 Shines Brighter with Three Years on the Books
The Geek almost revealed this last Sunday morning, while preparing a chart of Mississippi Magazine awards for coaches since COVID-19. Site editor Christine thought that putting “Atley” and “COTY” and “2023/26” in the same sentence gave away our new headline, so The Geek hit the “soft pedal” while saving this Sneak Preview for today. To pay off any suspense now, what’s very exciting about R-7’s coaching performance is that the 2023 year looks so much better for JHS after three years of results.
We’re working to restore postseason accolades that were lost in the server crash of 2024, or left unread in lonely social-media posts of 2021-23, before The Geek knew how to promote our blog to the masses, and when too many honors were thrown-in and buried in the standard fare in a vain effort to turn Facebook into a “Magazine.” It’s harder to glue player ratings back together from 2021 through 2023 – Hunter Bates and the Festus Tigers’ alumni wide receiving corps -are-still-missing- until further notice – however it’s actually easy to put the coach ratings back together without having every item on hand, since you win COTYs by improving a team drastically from their prior performance. That’s why it’s tough for Coach Ofodile or Coach Ray to win right now. Their 2025 teams were already dynamite! The Associated Press has gone 23 seasons without giving the award to a Super Bowl victor.
Here’s every gold and silver Small Schools coach ranking since 2021. The Gridiron Geek won’t insert much pesky commentary (first time for everything!) except on 2023, a season from which Atley’s Small Schools superiority shines even brighter as of today.
Top Small School Coaches of 2021-2025
2021
Dan Oliver, St. Pius Lancers (W/L improved from 3-7 to 8-3)
Runner Up: Dave Dallas, Grandview Eagles (Milestone Playoff Win)
2022
Dan Fox, Crystal City Hornets (W/L improved from 3-7 to 8-2)
Runner Up: Blane Boss, Herculaneum Blackcats (Milestone Winning Season)
2023
Matt Atley, Jefferson Blue Jays (W/L improved from 5-5 to 8-3)
Runner Up: Dan Fox, Crystal City (Upset Tipton in the Playoffs)
Atley was the objective best Small Schools coach in 2023. Dan Fox of Crystal City was the celebrity. The Geek was so glad to see Crystal City upset Tipton, 2025’s Class 1 Show-Me Bowl winner, in 2023’s postseason that he nicknamed Coach Fox “Norman Dale” and Kanden Bolton “Jimmy Chitwood.” But while Crystal had slumped to an 0-6 rivalry defeat at Herky, Jefferson High was waging yet another classic Senior Night battle with St. Vincent. Since then, many developments have made JHS’s 2023 look way shinier.
Jefferson played St. Vincent, St. Pius X, and Lift For Life a combined four times, scoring 91 points and surrendering just 83 points, while scoring two wins over rival SPX in the final year of the I-55 Conference. We didn’t know at the time that Ray would have St. Pius contending in Class 2 and eventually Class 3 before long – and we especially didn’t know that Lift For Life was becoming a powerhouse at the Large Schools level. Festus High’s bid to reach the Show-Me Bowl again in Class 4 could realistically be eliminated by L4L, which had assembled grown a squad that beat Westminster, Burroughs, and nearly Farmington in 2023.
Atley should have been the celebrity Small Schools coach at Mississippi Magazine. The problem was that by the time Jefferson got to its matchup with Lift For Life, the Hawks’ insularity had surpassed all secret-keeping that The Geek has ever accused any of our schools of in 10+ years of reporting. It was so frustrating that Lift For Life – frightened of eligibility scandals in the wake of Cardinal Ritter’s ? tainted legacy – was refusing to air much of its action through MSHSAA TV or upload anything too useful on HUDL, until prognosticators couldn’t eye-ball test the 2023 Varsity Hawks with the help of Eyes On Main. TGG finally gave up, and nicknamed Jefferson’s rivalry with Lift For Life “Three Little Pigskins,” as in “FOOTBALL TODAY – ABSOLUTELY NO ADMITTANCE,” then fell back in awe as Jefferson High nearly took down a future Class 4 tycoon, with the help of Atley’s modern and dynamic playbook.
2024
Frank Ray, St. Pius (winning at 5-6 over a weak field)
Runner Up: Adam Sims, Crystal City (fell in due to Jefferson’s late slump)
Atley looked good versus a field of .500-or-worse coaches in 2024, but his ‘Jays hit a late-year swoon that would reach into 2025.
2025
Frank Ray, St. Pius (winning at 9-6 over a strong field)
Runner Up: Cory Hanger, Grandview (W/L improved from 4-6 to 7-4)
Coach Boss deserves an honorable mention for his turnaround of 2025, and another solid record in 2026.
Coach Ray can still win his third straight Coach of the Year award this postseason by winning the Class 3 state championship. If the Lancers score a landmark win in the Class 3 semifinals, after needing an instant-classic comeback to win the Class 2 semis last season, Ray will at least earn consideration for a gold medal in this December’s set of Jefferson County coaching awards.
Will the site become a “Festus and St. Pius” site with only the two neighbors left in Week 13 again? Nope. For one thing, Jefferson R-7 is a Festus-area school, too. For another, how could anyone forget the bravery of Jefferson’s coaches, players, parents, and faculty in the wake of November’s effort? Jefferson football is not “eliminated.” The Blue Jays stay in our thoughts and prayers.
Varsity Tigers and Lancers alike should take inspiration from Jefferson’s unreal courage in the face of catastrophe, and maybe set about playing through pain in a way that pays honor to the ’26 Blue Jays. Whatever ouch-y that you’ve gotten on your big toe is nothing compared to what a legion of kids just persevered in R-7. If JHS’s pain can be gloried, so can anything in this world.
Photo Credit: Jefferson R-7 High School Facebook
